Since Oasis’s split, and before their latest reunion, both brothers have enjoyed successful solo careers, though they’ve taken very different paths.
Noel’s solo project, Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds, saw him move towards a more sophisticated, experimental sound. His music became more layered, blending psychedelic rock and electronic influences.
For fans who appreciated the depth of Noel’s songwriting in Oasis, this was a natural progression. Tracks like "If I Had a Gun" and "The Dying of the Light" show that Noel hasn’t lost his ability to write deeply emotional, introspective songs.
Liam’s solo career, on the other hand, has been all about recapturing the spirit of Oasis. With albums like As You Were and Why Me? Why Not, Liam has stayed true to the formula that made Oasis a household name—big, anthemic rock songs with massive choruses and undeniable swagger.
While Noel’s music evolved, Liam’s has remained rooted in the sound that fans loved.
The fashion divide between the brothers is just as distinct as their musical paths. Noel’s wardrobe has become more refined as he’s aged, favouring classic pieces likepolos and sleek jackets, reflecting his more mature sound.
Liam, meanwhile, has stuck to his signature look—oversized Mod parkas, Desert boots, and, of course, his ubiquitous hair styles. In many ways, their fashion choices mirror their music: Noel’s is thoughtful and considered, while Liam’s is brash and unapologetic.
The Voice vs The Vision – Who Carried Oasis?
At the heart of every Oasis debate is this question: who was more important, Noel or Liam?
Without Noel’s songwriting, there would be no Oasis—there’s no denying that. But would Noel’s songs have had the same impact without Liam’s raw, passionate delivery?
It’s a debate that has divided fans for years, and the answer probably lies somewhere in the middle.
Noel’s vision shaped the band, but Liam’s voice brought it to life.
Songs like "Live Forever" and "Don’t Look Back in Anger" would still be great without Liam’s vocals, but they wouldn’t have had the same cultural resonance. Likewise, while Liam’s vocals gave Oasis its edge, without Noel’s songwriting, that voice wouldn’t have had the platform it needed to shine.
The Fashion Icons – Who Wore It Better?
Beyond the music, both brothers became style icons in their own right. Noel’s classic Mod look, with his preference for tailored suits and understated style, has made him a quiet trendsetter.
His fashion sense is timeless—never over the top, but always cool.
Liam, on the other hand, embraced bold, statement pieces, from his iconic parkas to his Mazey’s oversized sunglasses.
His look is more rockstar, more brash, and as unforgettable as his voice.
Fan Loyalty – Noel vs Liam
Fan loyalty is as divided as ever. Noel’s fans admire his intelligence, his wit, and his unparalleled songwriting ability. They see him as the real creative force behind Oasis and respect his evolution as an artist.
Liam’s fans, however, love his raw charisma, his unapologetic attitude, and his refusal to change for anyone. For them, Liam is Oasis—the rockstar who lived the dream and gave them some of the best nights of nights of their lives.
The Verdict
So, who wins the ultimate Gallagher showdown?
The truth is, both Noel and Liam were integral to the success of Oasis. Without Noel’s songwriting genius, there would be no songs to sing, and without Liam’s voice and attitude, there’d be no spark. Together, they created something that defined a generation. Oasis wouldn’t have been Oasis without both of them.
And now we’re lucky enough to have them back together and with a reunion tour planned, so let’s hope this is the end of the arguing, and the future of Oasis is just as bright and electric as the past.